Pool Removal vs. Pool Renovation: Which Option Makes More Sense?

Deciding whether to renovate your existing swimming pool or remove it entirely can be a tough choice. Both options come with their own set of considerations, from cost and time to the impact on your home’s appeal. This article will help you weigh the pros and cons of Pool Removal vs. Pool Renovation to make the best decision for your property.

Key Takeaways

• Pool removal involves dismantling the pool structure, often filling the space with soil and other materials, while renovation focuses on repairing or upgrading existing features.
• Costs can vary significantly for both; removal might range from $10,000 to $20,000 or more depending on complexity, while renovations can also run into tens of thousands of dollars.
• Consider how often you actually use the pool. If it’s rarely used, the ongoing maintenance costs might make removal a more sensible financial choice.
• The condition of your current pool is a major factor. Extensive damage or outdated systems might push the renovation cost higher than removal.
• Think about your long-term plans for the space. Removing a pool frees up yard space for other uses, which could be more appealing for future resale or personal enjoyment.

Understanding the Core Differences

Deciding whether to remove or renovate your pool is a big choice, and it helps to know exactly what each option involves. Think of it like this: one is about starting fresh, and the other is about giving your existing pool a makeover.

Pool Removal: What It Entails

Pool removal means exactly what it sounds like – the complete or partial dismantling of your swimming pool. This process typically involves draining the pool, breaking up the concrete shell, and removing the debris. After the main structure is gone, the hole is filled with soil and compacted to create a stable base. A full pool removal is generally recommended if you plan to build on that area later, like adding a patio or even a shed, as it provides the most stable ground.

Here’s a general idea of what happens:

• Draining: The pool water is pumped out.
• Demolition: The pool shell (concrete, fibreglass, or vinyl liner) is broken up.
• Removal: The broken materials are hauled away.
• Backfilling: The excavated area is filled with soil and compacted.
• Restoration: The site is graded and prepared for its next use.

While it might seem straightforward, there can be hidden challenges. Unforeseen issues like old plumbing, electrical lines, or even groundwater can pop up, making the process a bit more involved than you might initially expect. It’s why having a good contractor is so important.

Pool Renovation: What It Entails

Pool renovation, on the other hand, focuses on updating and repairing your existing pool. This could involve anything from resurfacing the pool walls and floor to replacing tiles, upgrading the filtration system, or even changing the pool’s shape or features. The goal here is to improve the pool’s appearance, functionality, and efficiency, rather than removing it altogether.

Common renovation tasks include:

• Resurfacing: Applying new plaster, pebble, or tile to the pool’s interior.
• Tile Replacement: Updating or replacing the waterline tiles.
• Equipment Upgrades: Installing new pumps, filters, or heaters.
• Leak Repair: Fixing any structural leaks.
• Feature Additions: Incorporating new elements like water features or lighting.

Essentially, renovation keeps the pool but makes it better. It’s about breathing new life into your existing structure, often at a lower initial cost than a full removal, but it doesn’t give you back the yard space that removal does.

Key Factors to Consider for Your Decision

Deciding between removing your pool or renovating it is a significant choice, and it’s wise to weigh up a few important points before you commit. Think of it like deciding whether to fix up an old car or buy a new one – both have their own set of considerations.

Cost comparison: Removal vs. Renovation

Naturally, cost is a big one. Renovating an existing pool can sometimes seem cheaper upfront, especially if the structure is sound. However, you might be looking at ongoing repairs down the track. Removing a pool, while a larger initial outlay, means you’re essentially starting fresh with your backyard space and eliminating future pool-related expenses.

Here’s a general idea of what you might expect:

Note: These figures are estimates and can vary significantly based on pool size, materials, and specific project requirements.

Time Commitment for Each Project

How quickly do you need your backyard back? Renovations can take anywhere from a few weeks to a couple of months, depending on the scope of work. Pool removal, on the other hand, is often quicker. A complete removal typically takes about a week, sometimes a bit longer if there are unexpected issues.

Impact on Property Value and Resale

This is where things get interesting. While a beautifully renovated pool can be a major drawcard for some buyers, many potential homeowners today prefer a yard without the upkeep of a pool. Removing a pool can open up your yard for other uses, like a garden, play area, or even an extension, which can appeal to a broader market and potentially increase your property’s resale value.

Many real estate agents report that a well-maintained, empty yard often fetches a better price than a property with an aging or neglected pool, especially in areas where maintenance is a significant concern.

Maintenance and Ongoing Costs

Let’s be honest, pools are a commitment. Regular cleaning, chemical balancing, filter maintenance, and potential repairs all add up. If you’re finding the upkeep a burden, removal offers a clear path to eliminating these ongoing costs and the time spent on maintenance.

Future Plans For the Space

What do you envision for your backyard in the coming years? If you plan to build a patio, an outdoor kitchen, a shed, or even an extension to your home, removing the pool entirely will likely be the most practical solution. Partial removal might be an option if you only want to eliminate the water feature but still want a slightly sunken area, though complete removal usually offers more flexibility for future construction.

Consider these questions:

• Do you envision a large lawn for children or pets?
• Are you planning to install a deck or patio?
• Do you want to create a vegetable garden or a different type of landscaping?
• Is future construction on the site a possibility?

Your answers will strongly guide which option makes more sense for your long-term goals.

Making the Final Decision for Your Home

So, you’ve weighed the costs, considered the time, and thought about how each option might affect your property. Now it’s time to bring it all together and make the choice that feels right for you and your home.

Think about your long-term vision. Are you planning to stay in this home for many years, or is a sale on the horizon? If you’re planning to sell soon, a full pool removal might offer the broadest appeal and potentially a better return on investment, as many buyers prefer a blank canvas. If this is your forever home and you enjoy having a pool, renovation could be the way to go, especially if the existing structure is sound.

Consider the condition of your current pool. Is it a minor cosmetic issue, or are there significant structural problems? A pool with a failing liner and damaged decking might lean towards removal, whereas a pool that just needs a new coat of paint and some updated features could be a prime candidate for renovation.

Ultimately, the best decision hinges on your personal circumstances and priorities.

Here’s a quick recap to help you decide:

• Pool Removal: Ideal if you want to eliminate ongoing maintenance, create usable yard space for other purposes (like a garden or play area), or if the pool is beyond economical repair. It generally offers the biggest boost to property value for those not interested in pools.
• Pool Renovation: Suitable if you love your pool, it’s in good condition, and you’re looking to update its appearance or functionality. This can be more cost-effective than removal if the pool structure itself is sound.

Don’t forget to factor in the ‘what ifs’. What if your renovation costs spiral? What if removal uncovers unexpected issues? Getting detailed quotes for both scenarios can provide a clearer financial picture and help alleviate future surprises.

Conditions of the existing pool

Before you make a decision, it’s really important to take a good, honest look at the pool you’ve got right now. Is it just a bit tired, or is it a genuine money pit?

Think about the structure itself. Are there any big cracks in the concrete or tiles? Have you noticed any shifting in the walls? Sometimes, a small crack can turn into a major headache and a costly repair job pretty quickly. Persistent leaks are another big sign that things aren’t quite right. If you’re constantly having to top up the water, you’re not just wasting water, you’re likely wasting money too.

Then there’s the equipment. Pumps, filters, and heaters don’t last forever. If yours are old, they might be using a lot more electricity than they should, or they could be on the verge of breaking down completely. Replacing these can set you back a fair bit.

Consider these common issues:

• Structural Integrity: Look for cracks, shifting walls, or signs of water damage.
• Plumbing and Leaks: Are you losing water faster than you should? Pressure testing pipes can reveal hidden problems.
• Equipment Age and Efficiency: Old pumps and filters can be costly to run and maintain.
• Liner Condition (if applicable): For vinyl-lined pools, check for tears, fading, or a general worn appearance.
• Overall Aesthetics: Does the pool look dated or uninviting?

Sometimes, a pool that looks okay on the surface might have underlying issues that only become apparent during a renovation. It’s worth getting a professional opinion to understand the true condition of your pool’s shell and plumbing before committing to a major project.

If your pool is constantly needing repairs, costing a fortune in upkeep, and you’re barely using it, it might be time to consider a change. The condition of your current pool is a major factor in deciding whether renovation is a sensible investment or if removal is the more practical path forward.

Making Your Final Choice

So, you’ve looked at all the ins and outs of fixing up your pool versus getting rid of it. It’s a big decision, for sure. If you love your pool and use it a lot, giving it a facelift might be the way to go. But if it’s more of a hassle than a help, or if you’re just not using it much anymore, taking it out could actually be a smart move. It might cost a bit upfront, but think about the ongoing savings on upkeep and the extra space you’ll get back. Ultimately, the best choice really depends on what you want for your home and your lifestyle. Weigh up the costs, the effort, and how you see yourself using your backyard in the future.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the main difference between removing a pool and fixing it up?

When you remove a pool, you’re basically getting rid of it altogether. This usually means breaking up the old structure, filling the hole, and making the area usable for something else, like a garden or a patio. Fixing up a pool, or renovating it, means making it look better and work properly again. This could be anything from a fresh coat of paint and new tiles to more serious repairs and upgrades like new equipment.

How much does it generally cost to get rid of a pool?

The cost to remove a pool can change a fair bit depending on its size, what it’s made of, and how easy it is for workers to get to. Some people mention costs around $15,000, while others have seen prices closer to $20,000 or more, especially if special procedures are needed to remove concrete and pipes. It’s a good idea to get a few quotes from different companies to get a clear picture.

How long does it take to remove a pool?

Typically, getting rid of a pool takes about three to five days. This time includes draining any remaining water, breaking down the pool structure, taking away all the leftover bits, and then filling the space with soil or gravel. If you were thinking of doing it yourself, remember it’s a big job that needs a lot of time and effort.

Can removing a pool actually make my house worth more?

Yes, in many cases, getting rid of an old pool can boost your home’s value. This is especially true if the pool is old, needs a lot of work, or takes up a lot of your yard. Buyers might see a pool as a hassle rather than a plus, particularly if it’s not in great shape or if there aren’t many other pools around.

Are there any ways to save money when removing a pool?

You might be able to save some money by draining the pool yourself if local rules allow it. Also, choosing cheaper fill materials like a mix of soil and gravel instead of just soil can help. Some companies might offer discounts if they can recycle parts of the pool, or if you schedule the work during less busy times of the year.

What if I don’t want to remove it completely, but don’t want to swim in it either?

If you’re not keen on full removal but also don’t want the upkeep of a swimming pool, you could look into options like covering it with a deck. This way, you still have the space for other activities, and it might be less work than a full renovation or removal, though it’s important to check if this is a suitable option for your specific pool and yard.